Evidence of nonspecific transmission of California aster-yellows virus by leafhoppers
AuthorHenry H. P. Severin
Author AffiliationsHenry H. P. Severin was Entomologist in the Experiment Station.
Hilgardia 17(1):21-59. DOI:10.3733/hilg.v17n01p021. October 1945.
Abstract does not appear. First page follows.
It may be necessary to define two terms before proceeding with this paper. Specificity is the transmission of a particular virus by one or two closely related species of vectors. “When a virus can be transmitted only by one or two closely related insects and cannot be transmitted artificially (except by grafting) the insect transmission is considered obligatory” (Leach, 1940).3
Formerly it was assumed that a specific relation existed between each plant virus and its aphid vector. Among the viruses transmitted by aphids, specificity is now regarded as exceptional rather than common.
In the opinion of (Smith (1937)), a rather strong point in favor of a specific relationship between leafhopper and virus lies in the fact that certain plant viruses can be transmitted by only one species. Heretofore it has been assumed that the aster-yellows virus could be disseminated only by the aster leafhopper, Macrosteles divisus (Uhl.) = [Cicadula sexnotota (Foll.)], and by no other means except grafting and budding of the plant.
According to (Kunkel (1926)), the intimate and specific relation existing between the aster-yellows virus and its insect vector is important evidence that the causative entity is biological rather than chemical. (Leach (1940)) emphasizes the biological, obligatory, and highly specific transmission of viruses by leafhoppers.
There may be some viruses which can be transmitted by only one species of leafhopper. During the past thirty years many species of leafhoppers collected in sugar-beet fields were tested by the author for the transmission of the curlytop virus, but up to the present time no other vector is known except the beet leafhopper, Eutettix tenellus (Baker). According to (DeLong (1942)), the North American fauna of leafhoppers, north of Mexico, consists of 2,000 species belonging to about 150 genera. No other species of the genus Eutettix has been tested up to the present time. It is naturally assumed that closely related species in the same genus should be tested; on the other hand, species in genera belonging to different subfamilies may be vectors. The sugar beet is an introduced plant, and it may be possible that if leafhoppers are collected on native host plants of the virus, other vectors may be discovered. As will be discussed with aster yellows in this paper, host plants highly susceptible to the virus should be used instead of the sugar beet.
Herewith is presented evidence that the transmission of the aster-yellows virus by six species of phlepsid leafhoppers is not specific. The characters, distribution, and food plants of these six vectors are discussed in a companion paper (DeLong and Severin, 1945). It is evident in the following review of literature that the prevailing concept has in general favored specificity.
Abbott E. V., Ingram J. W. Transmission of chlorotic streak of sugar cane by the leafhopper, Draeculacephala portola. Phytopathology. 1942. 32(1):99-100.
Agati A. A., Sison P. L., Abalos R. A progress report on the rice maladies recently observed in central Luzon with special reference to the stunt or dwarf disease. Philippine Jour. Agr. 1941. 12(2):197-210.
Ball E. D. Beet leafhopper (Eutettix tenella). Utah Agr. Exp. Sta. Ann. Rept. 1906. 1904-1905:16
Ball E. D. The leafhoppers of the sugar beet and their relation to curly-leaf condition. U. S. Dept. Agr. Bur. Ent. Bul. 1909. 66(Pt. 4):31-52.
Bawden F. C. Plant viruses and virus diseases. 1943. Second revised edition Waltham, Mass.: Chronica Botanica Co. 294p.
Black L. M. A study of potato yellow dwarf in New York. New York (Cornell) Agr. Exp. Sta. Mem. 1937. 209:1-23.
Black L. M. Specific transmission of varieties of potato yellow-dwarf virus by related insects. Amer. Potato Jour. 1941. 18(8):231-33. DOI: 10.1007/BF02886543 [CrossRef]
Black L. M. Some viruses transmitted by Agallian leafhoppers. Amer. Phil. Soc. Proc. 1944. 88:132-44.
Brandes E. W. Artificial and insect transmission of sugar-cane mosaic. Jour. Agr. Research. 1920. 19:131-38.
California Agricultural Experiment Station. California Agricultural Experiment Station Annual Report. 1927-. 1928. 28:75-76.
Chardon C. E., Veve R. E. Sobre la transmisón del matizádo se la caña por medio de insectos. Rev. Agr. Puerto Rico. 1922. 9(2):9-20.
Davis E. W. Notes on the collection of the sugar beet leafhopper showing extensions of its known host range in British Columbia and to the coast in Washington and Oregon. Jour. Econ. Ent. 1927. 20:581-86.
DeLong D. M. The North American species of the subfamily Gyponinae. The Ohio State University 1942. pp.1-187. Graduate School monograph series. Contribution in Zoology and Entomology No. 5
DeLong D. M. Three new species of Texananus from the western and southwestern United States. Brooklyn Ent. Soc. 1943. 38:124-27.
DeLong D. M., Severin H. H. P. Characters, distribution, and food plants of phlepsid leafhopper vectors of California aster-yellows virus. Hilgardia. 1945. 17(1):1-20. DOI: 10.3733/hilg.v17n01p001 [CrossRef]
Dobroscky I. D. Cranberry false-blossom disease spread by a leafhopper. Science. 1929. 70:635 DOI: 10.1126/science.70.1826.635 [CrossRef]
Dobroscky I. D. Cranberry false-blossom disease and its insect vector. Boyce Thompson Inst. Contrib. 1931. 3:59-83.
Fawcett G. L. Encrespamiento de las hojas de la remolacha azucarera. Rev. Indus. y Agr. de Tucumán. 1925. 16:39-46.
Fawcett G. L. The curly top of the sugar beet in the Argentine Republic. Phytopathology. 1927. 13:458-60.
Frazier N. W. Phylogenetic relationship of the nine leafhopper vectors of Pierce’s disease of grape. (Abstract.) Phytopathology. 1945. 34:1000-01.
Fukushi T. An insect vector of dwarf disease of rice. [In Japanese.] Imp. Acad. Japan Proc. 1937. 13(8):328-31.
Hewitt W. B., Frazier N. W., Houston B. R. Transmission of Pierce’s disease of grapevines with a leafhopper. Phytopathology. 1942. 32:8
Hewitt W. B., Frazier N. W., Jacobs H. E., Freitag J. H. Pierce’s disease of grapevines. California Agr. Exp. Sta. Cir. 1942. 353:1-32. https://archive.org/details/piercesdiseaseof353hewi
Hill A. V. Big bud of tobacco. Austral. Council Sci. &; Indus. Res. Jour. 1937. 10:309-12.
Hill A. V. Yellow dwarf of tobacco. Austral. Council Sci. &; Indus. Res. Jour. 1941. 14(3):181-86.
Hill A. V. Insect transmission and host plants of virescence (big bud of tomato). Austral. Council Sci. &; Indus. Res. Jour. 1943. 16(2):85-90.
Ingram J. W. Insects that carry mosaic disease of sugarcane. Sugar Bul. 1937. 16(6):4-7.
Ingram J. W., Haley E., Charpentier L. J. Insect vectors of sugarcane mosaic in continental United States. Sixth Cong. Internatl. Soc. Sugar Cane Technol. Proc. 1939. 1938:483-94.
Ingram J. W., Summers E. M. Transmission of sugarcane mosaic by the rusty plum aphid, Hysteroneura setariae. Jour. Agr. Res. 1936. 52:879-88.
Ingram J. W., Summers E. M. Transmission of sugarcane mosaic by the green bug (Toxoptera graminum). Jour. Agr. Research. 1938. 56(7):537-40.
Ishikawa T. The merit of Hatsuzo Hashimoto, the earliest investigator of stunt disease of rice plant. [In Japanese.] Nippon Plant Protect. Soc., Jour. Plant Protect. (Byochugai Zasshi). 1928. 15:218-22.
Katsura S. The stunt disease of Japanese rice, the first virosis shown to be transmitted by an insect vector. Phytopathology. 1936. 26:887-95.
Kunkel L. O. Insect transmission of yellow stripe disease. Hawaii Planters Rec. 1922. pp.58-64.
Kunkel L. O. Studies on aster yellows. Amer. Jour. Bot. 1926. 13:646-705. Also in: Boyce Thompson Inst. Contrib. 1: 181-240. DOI: 10.2307/2435474 [CrossRef]
Kunkel L. O. Insect transmission of peach yellows. Boyce Thompson Inst. Contrib. 1933. 5:19-28.
Kunkel L. O. Plant viruses. Science. 1944. 99(2579):450-451. [A review of: Plant viruses and virus diseases, by F. C. Bawden. 2d ed. Chronica Botanica Company, Waltham, Mass. 1943.]
Leach J. G. Insect transmission of plant diseases. 1940. New York and London: McGraw-Hill Book Co. 615p.
Medler J. T. The leafhoppers of Minnesota. Minnesota Agr. Exp. Sta. Tech. Bull. 1942. 155:1-196.
Menzies J. D. Transmission studies with alfalfa witches’-broom. Phytopathology. 1944. 34:936
Oman P. W. South American leafhoppers of the genus Agalliana. Rev. de Ent. 1934. 4(3):333-40.
Osborn H., Lathrop F. H. The genus Phlepsius in North America. Ann. Ent. Soc. Amer. 1923. 16:310-62.
Ryjkoff V. L. Filterable virus as a cause of virescence of flowers. Rev. Appl. Mycol. 1935. 14:130-31.
Ryjkoff V. L., Karatchevsky I. K. Experiments on the artificial transmission of virus diseases of tomato. Rev. Appl. Mycol. 1935. 14:130 Abstracted in
Schindler A. J. Insect transmission of Wallaby ear disease of maize. Austral. Inst. Agr. Sci. Jour. 1942. 8(1):35-7.
Severin H. H. P. Minimum incubation periods of causative agent of curly leaf in beet leafhopper and sugar beet. Phytopathology. 1921. 11:424-29.
Severin H. H. P. Yellows disease of celery, lettuce, and other plants, transmitted by Cicadula sexnotata (Fall.). Hilgardia. 1929. 3(18):543-83. DOI: 10.3733/hilg.v03n18p543 [CrossRef]
Severin H. H. P. Life-history of beet leafhopper, Eutettix tenellus (Baker). California. Univ. California Pubs. Ent. 1930. 5:37-88.
Severin H. H. P. Modes of curly-top transmission by the beet leafhopper, Eutettix tenellus (Baker). Hilgardia. 1931. 6(8):253-76. DOI: 10.3733/hilg.v06n08p253 [CrossRef]
Severin H. H. P. Field observations of the beet leafhopper, Eutettix tenellus, in California. Hilgardia. 1933. 7(8):281-360. DOI: 10.3733/hilg.v07n08p281 [CrossRef]
Severin H. H. P. Transmission of California aster and celery-yellows virus by three species of leafhoppers. Hilgardia. 1934. 8(10):339-62. DOI: 10.3733/hilg.v08n10p337 [CrossRef]
Severin H. H. P. Potato naturally infected with California aster yellows. Phytopathology. 1940. 30(12):1049-51.
Severin H. H. P. Infection of perennial delphiniums by California aster-yellows virus. Hilgardia. 1942. 14(8):411-40. DOI: 10.3733/hilg.v14n08p411 [CrossRef]
Severin H. H. P., Haasis F. A. Transmission of California aster yellows to potato by Cicadula divisa. Hilgardia. 1934. 8(10):329-35. DOI: 10.3733/hilg.v08n10p327 [CrossRef]
Severin H. H. P., Henderson C. F. Beet leafhopper, Eutettix tenellus (Baker), does not occur in the Argentine Republic. Jour. Econ. Ent. 1928. 21(4):542-44.
Severin H. H. P., Henderson C. F. Some host plants of curly top. Hilgardia. 1928. 3(13):339-93. DOI: 10.3733/hilg.v03n13p339 [CrossRef]
Shaw H. B. The curly-top of beets. U. S. Dept. Agr. Bur. Plant Indus. Bul. 1910. 181:1-46.
Smith K. M. A textbook of plant virus diseases. 1937. Philadelphia, Penn.: P. Blakiston’s Son &; Co., Inc. 615p.
Smith R. E., Boncquet P. A. Connection of a bacterial organism with curly leaf of the sugar beet. Phytopathology. 1915. 5:335-42.
Storey H. H. The transmission of streak disease of maize by the leafhopper, Balclutha mbila Naude. Ann. Appl. Biol. 1925a. 12:422-39. DOI: 10.1111/j.1744-7348.1925.tb04238.x [CrossRef]
Storey H. H. Streak disease of sugar cane. Union So. Africa Dept. Agr. Sci. Bul. 1925b. 39:1-30.
Storey H. H. Interspecific cross-transmission of plant virus diseases. So. African Jour. Sci. 1926. 23:305-06.
Storey H. H. Transmission studies of maize streak disease. Ann. Appl. Biol. 1928. 15:1-25. DOI: 10.1111/j.1744-7348.1928.tb07034.x [CrossRef]
Storey H. H. A new virus of maize transmitted by Cicadulina spp. Ann. Appl. Biol. 1937. 24:87-94. DOI: 10.1111/j.1744-7348.1937.tb05022.x [CrossRef]
Storey H. H. Transmission of plant viruses. Bot. Rev. 1939. 5:240-72. DOI: 10.1007/BF02878491 [CrossRef]
Storey H. H., McLean A. P. D. The transmission of streak disease between maize, sugar cane, and wild grasses. Ann. Appl. Biol. 1930. 17(4):692-719. DOI: 10.1111/j.1744-7348.1930.tb07240.x [CrossRef]
Takata K. Results of experiments with the dwarf disease of rice. [In Japanese.] Jour. Japan. Agr. Soc. 1895-96. 171:1-4. 13-32.
Tate H. B., Vanderberg S. R. Transmission of sugarcane mosaic by aphids. Jour. Agr. Research. 1939. 59:73-79.
Thomas K. M., Krishnaswami C. S. Little leaf—a transmissible disease of Brinjal. Indian Acad. Sci. Proc. 1939. 10(2):201-12.
Walker J. C., Larson R. H. Yellow dwarf of potato in Wisconsin. Jour. Agr. Research. 1938. 59:259-80.